From-Scratch Baking in the Heart of Bloomington
Lizzie's Grove Street Bakery has been serving sweet treats and neighborly charm since 1996. Order online or stop in for a taste of tradition.
From-scratch baked goods made fresh daily with classic recipes
Nearly 30 years of history as Bloomington’s favorite neighborhood bakery
Woman-owned, LGBTQ+ friendly, and proudly community-centered
Known for our sugar cookies, cinnamon rolls, and custom designs
From-scratch baked goods made fresh daily with classic recipes
Nearly 30 years of history as Bloomington’s favorite neighborhood bakery
Woman-owned, LGBTQ+ friendly, and proudly community-centered
Known for our sugar cookies, cinnamon rolls, and custom designs
Welcome
Baking From Scratch Since 1996
Grove Street Bakery has been a cherished part of Bloomington since 1996. We’re more than just a place to grab a donut—we’re a neighborhood staple where generations of locals come for classic recipes and community warmth. Whether you're picking up a cinnamon roll on your way to work or planning custom cookies for a baby shower, we treat every order with handcrafted care. Under new ownership, our mission stays the same: preserve the bakery’s rich tradition while bringing delightful baked goods to every table.
ABOUT US
Treats for Every Occasion
Our menu covers every craving—from early morning donuts and coffee to elegant wedding desserts. Looking for famous sugar cookies? We’ve got them iced and ready. Need a custom cookie set for a party? We’ll bring your creative vision to life. Planning a cake for your event? Let’s talk about designs and flavors. We balance classic staples with custom orders, all with the same attention to freshness and flavor. Every order is made from scratch, just the way it should be.
why choose us
Why Neighbors Choose Us
Classic recipes, scratch baking, and friendly service since 1996.
Heading
We bake everything from scratch, honoring the original recipes that made us famous. Whether it's a cinnamon roll or a cake, quality never takes a day off.
Heading
Our bakery has served the Bloomington community since 1996. Generations of customers have walked through our doors—and keep coming back for a reason.
Heading
Grove Street Bakery is a woman-owned, LGBTQ+ friendly establishment, offering a safe and welcoming space for all. We believe in treating every guest like a neighbor.
Heading
From famous sugar cookies to wedding consultations, we specialize in both daily delights and one-of-a-kind celebrations.
Our Offerings
Desserts Designed for You
Thoughtfully crafted cookies and cakes for everyday cravings and special events
Cookie Customizations
Add writing or change colors on our famous sugar cookies. Great for birthdays, showers, or themed events.
Custom Cakes & Cookies
We design cookie sets and cakes to match your theme or vision—perfect for parties, showers, and birthdays.
Wedding Consultations
Meet with us to plan the perfect desserts for your big day. From elegant cookies to custom cakes, we’ve got you.
Online Ordering
Order donuts, cookies, and pastries online for quick pickup. Fresh, fast, and made from scratch every morning.
REVIEWS
What Our Customers Say
Beloved in Bloomington for decades—read why families come back generation after generation.
REVIEWS
What Our Clients Say
We’d love to hear about your experience with us! Your feedback not only helps us continue improving, but it also helps others feel confident in choosing our services. If we’ve made a positive impact, we’d truly appreciate you taking a moment to share your thoughts. Your review means a great deal to our team and plays an important role in supporting our business. Thank you for helping us grow!
FAQS
Your Questions, Answered
How far in advance should I place a custom order?
Please allow at least 48 hours for custom cookies and 72 hours for cakes. Detailed orders often book out 4–6 weeks in advance.
Do you offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Yes, as of February 2026, we offer cookies that are:
- Gluten-free
- Dairy-free
- Egg-free
- Tree nut-free
- Peanut-free
- Soy-free
We can decorate them just like our classic sugar cookies!
Same cute designs, same festive fun, with even more options for everyone!
What’s your refund policy for cancellations?
Cancel more than 48 hours before pickup for a full refund. Within 24 hours = 50% store credit. Same-day = no refund.
You must speak with our staff.
An email, voicemail, or a message with no reply does not equal a cancel.
Can I order online?
Yes! Use our Order Online link to order standard bakery items for quick pickup. For custom orders, please fill out the quote form on our Contact Us page.
Do you make highly detailed custom cookies?
Yes. We offer intricate theme-decorated sets. These require longer lead times and must meet minimum quantities.
